That fresh tattoo is finally yours! You picked the perfect design and sat through the buzzing needles. Now comes the most important part: making sure that beautiful new ink heals perfectly. Choosing the right aftercare cream feels like a huge task. Should you use a thick ointment, a light lotion, or something totally different? Many people worry about picking the wrong product and accidentally ruining their artwork or causing a painful infection.
This confusion is normal. The sheer number of tattoo aftercare products on the shelf can overwhelm anyone. You want your tattoo to look vibrant and clear, not dry, itchy, or faded. We understand that pain point—you invested time and money into your skin art and need reliable advice.
This post cuts through the noise. We will clearly explain what ingredients matter most, what creams to use in the early days, and which ones to avoid. By the end of this guide, you will feel confident choosing the absolute best cream to keep your new tattoo healthy, bright, and beautifully healed.
Top Cream To Put On New Tattoo Recommendations
- TATTOO AFTERCARE ESSENTIAL: Hustle Butter is the original tattoo aftercare balm for new and older tattoos. With over 10 years in the market, we are a pioneer of the tattoo aftercare category.
- TATTOO BALM SAFE FOR USE WHILE HEALING: Hustle Butter is not only safe for new tattoos but is the #1 artist recommended tattoo aftercare product to moisturize and nourish skin as the tattoo heals.
- MADE WITH VEGAN AND NATURALLY DERIVED INGREDIENTS: Certified cruelty-free and vegan, our tattoo balm is also petroleum free. It is made from only the finest naturally-derived ingredients, including Shea Butter, Coconut Oil, Mango Seed Butter and Green Tea Extract
- USED BY ARTISTS WORLDWIDE: Hustle Butter is the #1 brand used and recommended by artists, because they helped create it. Hustle Butter makes the full tattoo process better and more efficient for the artist and the client. Hustle Butter does not remove stencils or clog tubes allowing for colors to go in easier.
- THE MOST RECOGNIZED NAME IN TATTOO CARE: Back in 2011 Richie Bulldog and Seth Love, staples in the tattoo community, knew tattoos needed more care than what was available on the market. Through their experience with long and painful processes and uncomfortable heals, they made it their mission to build a superior product that could be used before, during, and after tattooing. With the perfection of our flagship product, Hustle Butter Deluxe, a brand was born.
- This Tattoo. -(Cleansing) - System removes your tattoos and Ink . The rich, whipped texture is easy to apply and quickly absorbs without a greasy - feeling.
- PROFESSIONAL FORMULA: Advanced t-at-too- removal -cream designed for maximum fading. This product is specifically- formulated to leave the skin supple, soft, and hydrated.
- Our cream-based formula ensures simplicity and excellence. It has a largely oil-(free), and (paraben)-free composition for a clean and gentle application.
- Experience a tattoo - removal regimen that embodies commitment to quality.
- Do not compromise when it comes to what you put on your skin.
- Numbing Cream Maximum Strength : Long Lasting Numbing Cream with 5x Numbing - Emu Oil and Arnica (1.7 OZ/50ml)
- Fast-Acting Formula, Less Waiting Time: Enhanced with proprietary compatibility technology, it accelerates absorption and numbing efficiency—working faster than traditional anesthetic creams to minimize wait time.
- Healing-Enhancing, Recovery Support: Infused with active ingredients like Arnica and Emu Oil, it penetrates deeply to soothe, moisturize, and repair skin. Promotes faster healing, reduces scabbing, and lowers the risk of infection.
- Fragrance-Free, Oil-Free, Non-Greasy: Lightweight texture leaves no residue, contains no harsh chemicals or oils. Easy to apply and remove without staining clothes.
- Simple Application, Safe to Use: Apply to clean skin and allow time to take full effect. Patch test recommended before first use to ensure compatibility.
- Rich Shea Butter Nourishment: Formulated specifically for tattoo aftercare, our balm is infused with natural shea butter. It works to moisturize tattooed skin, leaving it feeling supple and comforted. This helps to improve the feel of your skin and maintain its elasticity.
- Revitalizes Tattoo Appearance: This tattoo aftercare cream helps improve color presentation of your tattoo, making the artwork appear more vibrant. With regular use, this tattoo balm assists in maintaining the visual appeal of your body art.
- Calms Skin Irritation: Its mild formulation offers soothing comfort. Helps alleviate skin sensitivity and minimizes typical irritation that may follow new tattoos.
- Aids Skin Recovery: Works in harmony with the skin’s natural renewal process by providing moisture and a protective barrier, while helping maintain the appearance of tattooed skin.
- Plant-Based, Lightweight & Non-Greasy: Formulated with a natural plant-based formula that absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy feel, providing a comfortable experience as part of your tattoo aftercare routine.
- Tattoo Aftercare Essential: Our tattoo aftercare balm is suitable for both new and healed tattoos. It is designed to aid in the healing process and reduce irritation for new tattoos, while also rejuvenating older tattoos, and ensures they receive optimal care.
- Enhance & Maintain Your Ink: This ultra-nourishing balm instantly enhances ink vibrancy while forming a protective barrier on skin to help moisturize and soothe. An essential tattoo supply for all stages of tattoo care, use before, during, and after tattooing. The compact tin makes it super convenient to apply whenever needed.
- Deep Nourishment: Infused with natural botanical extracts, our tattoo balm penetrates deeply to nourish, repair damage, and accelerate healing. It promotes fast, effective healing of new tattoos while soothing dryness-related itch.
- Sensitive-Skin Friendly: Designed specifically for sensitive skin, our tattoo aftercare butter delivers a gentle, nurturing formula to soothe and protect. Whether it’s a new tattoo or an addition to your collection, our butter ensures optimal healing and vibrant tattoo longevity.
- Suitable for All Skin Types and Ink Colors: Don't worry about compatibility! Our tattoo balm is universally versatile for all skin types and ink colors. It can be used before, during, and after tattooing, keeping skin nourished and tattoos vibrant.
- SUPERIOR HEALING: Get everything you need to heal your tattoo & keep it looking as good as the day you got it. Maintain & enhance vibrant color with this 3-piece Tattoo Care Kit. It includes everything you need to care for new ink, help it heal quickly & keep colors bright (reducing the need for expensive touch-ups). Plus, you can’t beat the savings when you buy the full aftercare suite together.
- ANTIMICROBIAL SOAP: Get broad-spectrum antimicrobial & antibacterial protection in a pH balanced formula. Unscented & alcohol-free, our deep cleansing soap is a gentle way to disinfect fresh ink & help prevent infections. Formulated with premium grade moisture-rich olive oil, this soap deeply cleanses to remove dead skin & dirt while minimizing irritation, dryness & leaves no residue.
- HEALING BALM: Formulated with 60%+ olive oil, lavender oil & only all-natural ingredients, our balm is the original go-to for ink that is healing or healed. Our rich balm is made to mimic the natural oils that occur in your skin so it goes on smoothly & absorbs well for moisturized skin & vibrant ink.
- AFTERCARE LOTION: This light lotion prevents scabbing & speeds the healing process. Moisturizing with the bonus of itch relief, our lotion soothes healing skin & keeps healed ink looking sharp for life! Formulated with Olive Oil & Panthenol, our lotion provides essential oils & Vitamin B5 to deeply re-moisturize dry skin, essential during the healing process. This antioxidant rich formula is also perfect for older tattoos to bring back color and stimulate collagen!
- CERTIFIED DERMATOLOGIST TESTED: Tattoo Goo products are pharmacist developed & supported by clinical studies confirming Tattoo Goo After Care products are not associated with skin irritation or allergic dermatitis (inflammation of the skin). Cruelty Free, Petroleum Jelly & Lanolin-free & proudly made in the USA. Apply with confidence!
- HEALING BALM - Made with the finest blend of humectants, essential oils and premium natural ingredients for moisturization, anti-oxidation, and stimulation of circulation. Designed to help the skin heal itself for vibrant new tats.
- ANTIOXIDANT SUPPORT - No preparation has more antioxidant activity than Tattoo Goo. We use quality pumice grade olive oil to help manage the skin healing process along with wheat germ oil, loaded with the antioxidant vitamin E, and rosemary extract.
- MOISTURIZER & BRIGHTENER - With 98% natural healing ingredients including triglycerides, olive oil, lavender, cocoa butter, and wax ester beeswax to help soothe inflammation, lubricate and moisturize. Petroleum and lanolin-free, never tested on animals.
- AVOID DRIED OUT TATS - Using aftercare products does not allow the tattoo to dry out. It makes a tattoo softer and promotes quicker healing by keeping the area lubricated and moist. Compact tin makes it super convenient to apply whenever needed.
- CERTIFIED DERMATOLOGIST TESTED - The product is pharmacist developed and clinical studies confirm Tattoo Goo after care products are not associated with skin irritation or allergic dermatitis (inflammation of the skin). Apply with confidence!
- 2-in-1 Tattoo Care for New & Old Ink – Heal, protect, and brighten your tattoos with this 2-pack tattoo balm. Specially formulated for both fresh ink and older pieces, it works as a complete tattoo aftercare cream, soothing irritation while reviving faded colors—perfect as part of your tattoo goo aftercare kit.
- Anti-Fade Protection + Color Enhancement – Locks in moisture to help reduce ink discoloration over time. Use daily to maintain vibrant clarity on black, grey, or color tattoos. This rich tattoo butter formula also acts as a gentle tattoo moisturizer, keeping your art looking freshly done.
- 100% Vegan & Cruelty-Free Healing – Made without animal-derived ingredients or testing, this plant-based tattoo healing cream supports the skin’s natural repair process. Ideal for sensitive skin, it promotes faster recovery for new tattoos while nourishing older ones. Comparable to top favorites like Hustler Butter tattoo balm or Papatui tattoo care.
- Deep Hydration & Quick Absorption – Lightweight, non-greasy, and fast-absorbing, this tattoo lotion aftercare delivers instant moisture to prevent dryness, flaking, and itching—without clogging pores. Works great alongside a tattoo ointment or tattoo cover up patch for extra protection.
- Portable & Mess-Free Application – The convenient roller brush design makes applying your tattoo balm aftercare simple, clean, and travel-ready. Perfect for on-the-go use, whether you’re heading to the studio, gym, or vacation
The Essential Buying Guide for Your New Tattoo Cream
Getting a new tattoo is exciting! Taking care of it is super important. The right cream helps your skin heal well and keeps your new ink looking bright. This guide will help you choose the best cream for your fresh artwork.
Key Features to Look For
When you shop, look for creams that do a few main things well.
- **Moisturizing Power:** The cream must keep your tattoo skin soft and hydrated. Dry skin cracks and pulls at the healing layers. A good moisturizer prevents this.
- **Soothing Ingredients:** Healing skin often feels itchy or a little sore. Look for ingredients that calm this feeling down quickly.
- **Non-Greasy Feel:** You want a cream that sinks into your skin, not one that sits on top like thick grease. Greasy creams can clog pores and trap moisture, which is bad for healing.
- **Odorless or Light Scent:** Strong smells can irritate sensitive, healing skin. Choose unscented or very lightly scented products.
Important Ingredients: What to Seek Out
The ingredients list tells the real story about the cream’s quality. Focus on natural, gentle items.
Good Ingredients Include:
- **Shea Butter or Cocoa Butter:** These are rich moisturizers that lock in hydration without being too heavy.
- **Aloe Vera:** This famous plant is excellent for soothing redness and inflammation. It cools the skin down fast.
- **Vitamin E:** This vitamin helps skin repair itself. It supports the healing process naturally.
- **Beeswax (in moderation):** A little beeswax creates a protective barrier over the tattoo, shielding it from dirt while still letting it breathe.
Factors That Improve or Reduce Cream Quality
Not all tattoo creams are made equal. Some things boost the quality, and others lower it.
What Makes a Cream Better:
- **Natural Basis:** Creams made mostly from natural oils and butters tend to be gentler on damaged skin.
- **Dermatologist Tested:** If experts have checked the formula, it usually means it is safe for sensitive skin.
- **Air Permeability:** The best creams allow your skin to breathe. Healing needs air!
What Makes a Cream Worse:
- **Petroleum Jelly (Vaseline):** While it protects, it often seals the skin too tightly. Too much petroleum jelly can trap bacteria and slow down healing. Use it only very lightly, if at all, according to your artist’s advice.
- **Artificial Dyes and Parabens:** These chemicals can cause allergic reactions on fresh, open wounds. Avoid them!
- **Heavy Fragrances:** These are common irritants that can make your healing tattoo itchy and red.
User Experience and Use Cases
How the cream feels and when you use it matters a lot.
When you first use the cream, you want it to feel cool and immediately reduce that tight, burning sensation. You should apply a thin layer several times a day—usually three to five times. Always wash your hands before touching the tattoo!
Use Case 1: The First Few Days (The Oozing Stage): During this time, your tattoo might still weep a little plasma. You need a very light, healing-focused balm. Do not smother the tattoo. A thin layer is enough.
Use Case 2: The Itchy Stage (Days 4-10): This is when the intense itching starts. You need a cream with strong soothing ingredients, like aloe vera, to calm the itch without you scratching the ink off.
A high-quality cream should make the healing process feel less annoying and help your new art settle into your skin perfectly.
10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About New Tattoo Cream
Q: How often should I put the cream on my new tattoo?
A: You should apply a very thin layer about three to five times a day, or whenever your skin feels dry or tight. Always clean your hands first!
Q: Can I use regular lotion on my new tattoo?
A: It is better to use a cream specifically made for tattoos, especially for the first week. Regular lotions often have too many perfumes or chemicals that can irritate the fresh wound.
Q: When should I start using the cream?
A: Your tattoo artist will tell you exactly when to start. Usually, you apply the first layer after you take off the initial bandage, about two to three hours after getting tattooed.
Q: Is it okay if my cream feels a little greasy?
A: A tiny bit of richness is fine, but if it feels super greasy and sits on top of the skin, it is too heavy. Heavy creams stop the tattoo from breathing and healing properly.
Q: What if my tattoo starts peeling? Should I use more cream?
A: Peeling is normal! Gently pat on a little extra cream to soothe the peeling skin. Do not pick or rub the peeling flakes off. Let them fall off naturally.
Q: Can I use coconut oil instead of a special cream?
A: Some people use pure coconut oil successfully. However, specialized tattoo creams are often better because they have a balanced mix of healing agents like Vitamin E and do not clog pores as easily.
Q: Does the cream help with tattoo fading?
A: Yes, by helping the skin heal quickly and staying moisturized, the cream helps lock the ink in place. A well-healed tattoo fades much slower.
Q: What should I do if my tattoo looks really red after applying the cream?
A: If the redness gets worse, stop using that cream immediately. You might be reacting to an ingredient. Switch to a very simple, unscented product like plain Aloe Vera gel and call your tattoo artist.
Q: Should I use the cream before bed?
A: Yes! Applying a thin layer right before you go to sleep is great. Your skin repairs itself most actively while you sleep.
Q: Does the cream protect my tattoo from the sun?
A: No. Tattoo creams are for healing. You must wait until the tattoo is fully healed (usually 3-4 weeks) before using any sunscreen on it.